If Attacking Competitors Is Ok For Election Campaigns, Is It Ok For Tenders?

The concept of ‘ghosting’ competitor offerings in tenders is a well-known persuasion technique. Negative persuasion is proven to be extremely effective.

But, in BidWrite’s experience, most Australian organisations are reluctant to use this technique. They believe it to be a bit ‘grubby’.

Procurement professionals we talk to echo similar sentiments. In essence, they tell us that some competitive comparison in tenders is OK, but devoting lots of tender real estate to bad mouthing competitors is not appealing.

But this doesn’t change the fact that use of negative reinforcement and sowing the seeds of doubt persuades. Which is why, presumably (and despite earlier assurances to the contrary), Australian federal election campaigning is now dominated by attack ads.

So, here’s our conundrum. If it’s a known effective persuasive technique, and practiced widely in certain circumstances, why shouldn’t ghosting be used more in tendering?

Of course, there must be a limit. Defamatory language and untruths are not OK. But in ever-increasingly competitive bidding situations, inside sourcing processes that make it harder and harder to argue points of competitive difference, why would we limit ourselves to only part of the persuasive toolkit.

There is a clear case to drive tender ghosting harder. If it’s OK for people who want to run our country, surely, it’s good for organisations trying to win and retain business too.

BACK TO ALL BLOGS>

Subscribe to BidTalk

BidTalk is an emailed newsletter containing news, tips and information about our upcoming training events.

We use MailChimp to distribute this newsletter. By clicking Subscribe, you acknowledge that the information you provide will be sent to MailChimp for processing in accordance with their Privacy Policy and Terms.

Privacy: Email addresses are never sold or distributed to a third party. The mailing list is password-protected and is only used for sending announcements from BidWrite. No spam, no discussions.

How to Unsubscribe: It’s easy. Click the unsubscribe link at the bottom of each email newsletter to be removed from the mailing list.